please give the deference between manuel and automatic

Tell us more about yourself

 

Please let us know your details to help us answer your question.

 

 

 
please give the deference between manuel and automatic transmission.advantages and dis advantages.it is heard that in the case of break down it is very difficult for repairs in automatic version.if the breakdown happens on the road we have to take it to the service station.please give advice on the difficulties and advantages.thank you.
  • 2199 day(s) ago by Jose Joseph
Under: Maruti Suzuki  #Cars
5
Answer(s)
Post an Answer

Answers submitted by Users


Venkateshwaran
Maruti
Baleno
Owner
Yes you are correct t takes a lot of money to replace an Auto Transmission gear box. These cars are good for ladies who want to be relaxed while driving with little effort and control.
But for the driving enthusiast it gives little control and less power in a slow regulated fashion.
Imagine you want to overtake and you have very little time you can easily shift to a lower gear and wiz past in a manual transmission but in auto transmission even though there is a selection for uphill climb this is not as much fun. So if you are selecting a car for your better half you know what to buy.
 

Posted: 2199 day(s) ago


Shekhar Bandaru
Hyundai
Getz Prime
Owner
Apart from what Mr.Venkateshwaran has mentioned, In Auto transmission also, there will be gears and gearbox, but you need not operate the gears manually. As per the speed gears are changed automatically. The difference is same like a motorcycle and a gearless scooter like Activa. With Auto gears, mileage also decreases compared to manual. An YES, very less mechanics would be able to repair Auto gearbox. For small issues, there won't be much difference between manual and AT cars.
 

Posted: 2198 day(s) ago


Sam
Hyundai
i10
Owner
I have used automatic cars in India and outside India for more that 27 years. Different brands and models starting from Nissan Stansa, Toyoto Corolla, Corona, Ford Taurus, Lexus etc and some vehicles did up to 200,000 Kms I never experienced not even a small defect in A/T gear box. Now I am using Hyundai i 10 A/T for the last 3 years on very bad roads with no problems. Whether for city drive or for long drive A/T is extremely convenient as we have one hand and 1 leg totally free. Overtaking with I 10 is much more easy than manual transmission. Only apply the acceleration slightly more, the vehicle automatically shifts to 2nd gear at a musct higher speed that manual. Gear box is so well designed to last for the life of a vehicle. Other than the gear box, rest everything is same for A/T & M/T. Fuel consumption depends upon the way you accelerate and apply brake. Some new vehicles have 7 gear positions in A/T and is dead smooth on roads.
 

Posted: 2198 day(s) ago


Venkateshwaran
Maruti
Baleno
Owner
All said have you heard the engine RPM rise for a long time before the vehicle nudges forward and in the mean time one tends to floor the accelerator and this excessive wear reduces the life of the engine.
If you want proof drive behind a Marcopolo bus and hear the engine noise before the vehicle picks up reasonable speed.
For the information of one and all it is scientifically proved that Men can handle vehicles at tricky situations and so more women prefer the automatic which reduces the hand and leg work. Some Men also prefer the automatic maybe because it costs more.
 

Posted: 2198 day(s) ago


Advantage of Manual Transmission
1.Cheaper in price
2.Maintenance is easier
3.Very common and with improvement in technology, slight push of lever is enough to engage gears.
Disadvantage
1.The driver has to operate clutch pedal for engaging/disengaging gears.
Advantage of Automatic transmission
1.Holding of lever and pressing button is enough for clutch operation.
2.Easy to choose required gears.
Disadvantage
1.Costly around 40k excess compared to Manual gearbox
2.Though frequency of maintenance is less.Maintenance cost would be higher compared to MT

http://www.cartrade.com/auto-guides/transmission-in-a-car-engine-workings-and-details-113440.html
 

Posted: 2188 day(s) ago


Post Your Answer Here

Type the characters you see in the image below

Recently Asked Questions

Find New Cars

By Brand

Get complete details of new cars

By budget

5 Lakhs to 10 Lakhs

Ad
Ad