Shiva Shankar
Expert

Hi,
Tata Manza is very much improved compared to Indigo and eCS.Its reliable in performance and has advantage of sedan with separate boot space.Considering overall parameters such as utility for long term,build quality maintenance etc Indigo Manza Quadrajet would be a satisfactory selection.

Ranjan

I would suggest go for I20 as at the end of the day you need satisfaction on overall performance of your car. I20 gives power, looks, beautiful interior, maneuvering, long term relation and compact look.

Siddharth Bhomkar

its an unfair comparison. i20 is a driver's delight and manza is a traveller's. the i20 is a bit tight on space / manza has oodles of it with a wonderful boot to match. the one most annoying thing i found in the i20 was the plastic panel hitting my shin every now n then (at 5'10", i dont consider myself to be very tall)..wid manza, i guess it wud be the annoying rear design n wid tata, u may expect niggling creaks n rattles after some 12-18 months. but i wud still go for the manza for its sheer utility value. P.S. i have owned an indica turbo n lovd it. recently got a used verna diesel and am loving it a lot too

Jatin Bhayana

Dont go for both of them because:-
1. Hyundai diesel engine is worst
But petrol is the best.
2.Yaarr TATA Is noway?????

Either go for swift desire diesel
or buy a petrol best car kk
Hope you will think and buy the best..

Shiv Bhagwan

undoubtedly go for New Varito diesel top model super luk with gud quality. otherwise wait for mini xylo or luk for Renault Duster

Nitin Gupta

i have I 20 Asta (P) as well as Tata manza too (P) , no doubt looks wise , interior (fine finish)wise hyundai is good . but looking for space n features then manza is better with average interior (plastic looks) .
how often a person sells a car ....only after 3 to 4 yrs ..(mostly) , in such long time ur requirement will be more , so look forward for Sedan than hatchback.
y don't u try with Nissan Sunny , big space , good features , she's far better than Tata .
i would suggest u to have test drive with Sunny n i believe u'll love it .
do write me
guptanitin16@gmail.com
honestly both

Salman

anyday go for i20 its powerful, comfort and stylish will turn heads on for sure if maintained and dressed well

Govardhan

Dear Akshay,
Tata manza may look like its a good VFm (Value for money) at the first sight. But then the quality of things go very bad when you compare it with I20. I20 is loaded with features leaving Manza look bare. I20 may have less boot space, but in rear space it is almost in par with the manza. But the fit and finish, build quality, powerful engine, torque at low RPM, easy drive-ability, easy maneuvering etc etc speaks in favour of I20. I myself have an I20 and love the way car looks, feels and flies on the highway. IT also feels very good on the bumper to bumper traffic. it is not a smaller car as compared to manza. The engine noise is very less in I20 when compared to manza. If you want to live a trouble free, futuristic life, then i20 would be a better bet.

Kaka

i20 s good option